The Whispers of Concern: Jamie Carragher`s Scrutiny
The collective anxiety surrounding Anfield`s current state found its most articulate voice in Liverpool legend and CBS Sports analyst, Jamie Carragher. His assessment was blunt, cutting through any lingering optimism with the precision of a seasoned defender. “It`s concerning,” Carragher stated, but importantly, he elaborated that the issue extends far beyond the recent back-to-back defeats. According to him, the entire nine-game season has been a source of genuine worry, a concern he voiced to the manager as early as the first league game against Bournemouth, despite Liverpool ultimately winning 4-2.
Carragher`s most striking analogy perhaps best encapsulates the problem: “I don`t feel like I`m watching a top team. Liverpool aren`t playing football at the moment, they`re playing basketball, it`s end to end, and I don`t think top teams play like that.” This isn`t merely about tactics; it`s about control, structure, and the inherent dominance expected of a side that just clinched the league title. The implication is clear: the team has sacrificed defensive solidity and measured build-up for an overly open, chaotic style of play, which, while sometimes exciting, is unsustainable for championship contention.
A Squad Out of Sync: Tactical Tangles and Player Puzzles
The current struggles are not solely down to a lack of effort; rather, they appear to be a complex interplay of tactical misfires, player adaptations, and squad balance issues. Coach Slot, a manager who had a remarkably “smooth ride” last season, now finds himself in the crucible, tasked with earning his substantial salary by solving a series of intricate problems.
Wirtz`s Uncomfortable Fit and the New Role Dilemma
A prime example of the squad`s misalignment is Florian Wirtz. Hailed as a prodigious talent from Bayer Leverkusen, his transition to the Premier League and Liverpool has been far from seamless. At Leverkusen, Wirtz was the undisputed orchestrator, averaging 78 touches per 90 minutes, generating impressive xA and xG numbers. At Liverpool, however, his touch count has plummeted to 60 per 90, and while his chance creation remains respectable, his shooting output has halved. This isn`t just a matter of individual form; it`s a systemic issue. Asked to play a different, less central role in an attack focused on Mohamed Salah, Wirtz appears stifled, his prodigious talent struggling to find an outlet within Liverpool`s current framework. As Carragher shrewdly notes, Wirtz`s current struggle is “hurting the balance of the squad.”
Positional Migrations and Defensive Gaps
The team`s tactical integrity has also been compromised by players being deployed out of their natural positions. Dominik Szoboszlai, a dynamic midfielder with an eye for a pass and a strong defensive work rate, found himself at right-back against Galatasaray, where he unfortunately conceded the penalty that led to the lone goal. Similarly, Jeremie Frimpong, a key summer signing, has been shifted to the wing, a role typically occupied by Salah, despite excelling as a wing-back at Leverkusen. While Slot may value Frimpong`s attacking contributions, this constant repositioning creates instability and prevents players from settling into rhythm.
Defensively, the situation appears particularly precarious. The sale of Jarell Quansah to Leverkusen, where he immediately became a starter, now seems like an ill-timed decision given Ibrahima Konate`s recent struggles. With Giovanni Leoni`s season over and Stefan Bajcetic injured, Liverpool`s central defensive corps is alarmingly thin, leaving Virgil van Dijk, Joe Gomez, and Konate as the only natural center-backs. This lack of depth forces Slot into uncomfortable compromises, blurring positional lines in a way that often undermines collective defensive efforts.
The Coach`s Crucible: Arne Slot`s Uncharted Waters
Arne Slot inherited a team that had just achieved remarkable success. His first season was expected to be challenging, but few anticipated such a rapid accumulation of issues. Last season, it took 27 matches for Slot`s team to register their second loss across all competitions. This season, that unwelcome milestone arrived in just nine games. This stark contrast highlights the magnitude of the task at hand. The `charmed life` of last season, as it were, has given way to a gritty reality where every decision is scrutinized, and every performance is measured against a very high, recently set, bar.
Four new players started against Galatasaray, signifying the financial investment and the expectation that these new faces would play critical roles. Slot`s immediate challenge is to integrate these talents, find their optimal positions, and restore the team`s identity and game plan, which, as Carragher notes, “they need to regain this season.” Time is a luxury Slot doesn`t have, especially with a crucial clash against Chelsea looming and Arsenal breathing down their necks in the Premier League table.
Pathways to Revival: Charting a Course Correction
While the problems are multi-faceted, some solutions seem relatively straightforward, at least in concept. The path back to consistency will require decisive action and a clear tactical vision:
-
Reclaiming the Midfield Engine: Move Szoboszlai Back
Much of Liverpool`s success last season hinged on the dynamism of Alexis Mac Allister and Dominik Szoboszlai in midfield. Their high defensive work rates combined with attacking flair provided crucial balance. With Conor Bradley now available, Slot has an option at right-back, freeing Szoboszlai to return to his preferred, and more effective, central midfield role. Restoring this partnership could be the catalyst for regaining control in the engine room, providing both defensive cover and creative impetus.
-
Unlocking Frimpong`s Potential: Find a Consistent Role
Jeremie Frimpong`s talent is undeniable, but his deployment needs clarity. While starting him on the wing showcases his attacking prowess, his most effective role at Leverkusen was as a wing-back, allowing him to surge forward from deeper positions. If Liverpool is hesitant to commit to a consistent back three, Slot must find a way to unleash Frimpong`s attacking capabilities without compromising the team`s defensive structure. Consistency in his role will be key to helping him adapt and thrive.
-
Defensive Reinvention: Is Gravenberch a Center-Back?
The dire situation at center-back demands creative thinking. With injuries and departures, the club is alarmingly short of natural options. Positional flexibility has been a hallmark of this Liverpool squad, and it might be time to explore unconventional solutions. Ryan Gravenberch, who has occasionally dropped deeper in a back three, could potentially be trialed as a center-back in a back four, particularly if his midfield contributions are not consistently impactful. While not his natural position, the current circumstances may necessitate such experimentation until the January transfer window offers an opportunity for reinforcements. It`s a pragmatic, if perhaps slightly desperate, consideration.
Conclusion: The Urgency of Identity
Liverpool finds itself at a critical juncture. The Premier League title, so confidently secured last season, now feels like a distant memory amidst current uncertainties. While they still sit atop the league by a slender margin, the looming clash with Chelsea and Arsenal`s relentless pursuit serve as stark reminders of the intense pressure. Mikel Arteta`s Arsenal knows its identity; Liverpool, under Arne Slot, is currently in the process of rediscovering theirs. The task is formidable, the expectations immense. The question isn`t just about winning games; it`s about reclaiming the formidable, cohesive identity that made them champions. Can Slot find the answers before the season`s narrative takes an even more unsettling turn?
Gareth Fenton